Enron Mail

To:sharon.butcher@enron.com, michelle.cash@enron.com
Subject:FW: my unfair treatment at Enron--please HELP
Cc:kenneth.lay@enron.com, mark.frevert@enron.com
Bcc:kenneth.lay@enron.com, mark.frevert@enron.com
Date:Thu, 18 Oct 2001 08:44:59 -0700 (PDT)

I would appreciate your looking into this issue. Thank you. Jim
-----Original Message-----
From: Daw, Nicki On Behalf Of Frevert, Mark
Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2001 10:35 AM
To: Seleznov, Ryan; Oxley, David
Cc: 'ken.lay@enron.com'; Whalley, Greg; Derrick Jr., James; Kean, Steven J.; Mcconnell, Mike; Olson, Cindy; Fleming, Rosalee; Taylor, Liz; McVicker, Maureen; Harris, Stephanie J
Subject: FW: my unfair treatment at Enron--please HELP


Could you please follow up on this a.s.a.p? I don't think it should wait until Cindy returns to the office.

Thank you.


-----Original Message-----
From: Mingchenglian@aol.com [mailto:Mingchenglian@aol.com]
Sent: 17 October 2001 23:42
To: ken.lay@enron.com
Cc: Whalley, Greg; Frevert, Mark; jim.derrick@enron.com; Kean, Steven J.; Mcconnell, Mike; Olson, Cindy
Subject: my unfair treatment at Enron--please HELP

Ms. MingchengLian

Dear Mr. Lay,

My employment with Enron is to be terminated, the reason given by HR, for not meeting performance standards. However, I firmly believe that this is not the real reason, the real one being for defying the wishes of my manager (Mr. Lowell Bezanis,Manager, EGM) who, I believe was acting in a discriminatory way towards me. I have since filed a written complaint to Enron's EEO Committee.

This committee, having investigated the case, has acknowledged that there were working environment issues but has refused to provide me with a written report of their findings. As a consequence, my reasonable request for a re-deployment package has been rejected.

If my employment is to be prematurely terminated I not only lose my job, but also my residence status in the US where I have lived in the past 8 years. The HR department is fully aware of my situation and I feel that they were taking advantage of this fact when they asked me to sign a waiver not to sue Enron in exchange for protecting my status for 30 days. I now feel that I am being pushed into a corner, unnecessarily, since all I have set out to achieve is to bring an awareness of the working conditions and the discrimination which is rife (not only towards myself but also to other employees, some of whom have left as a result) in the department and to move forward with practicable solutions.

I have enjoyed a number of years as an employee of Enron where I have performed to the best of my ability, often receiving compliments from clients. This cannot be the only way to solve this issue!

The Trigger and Retaliation.

Since Mr. Bezanis has been my line manager, internal training opportunities have repeatedly been denied to me. On August 28, I attended a class of 'natural gas structuring'. Mr. Bezanis called the Learning Center refusing to pay the associated costs, however, I was welcomed to remain in the class at no charge.

I felt that this situation could not continue and so I made an appointment with Ms. Shanna Funkhouser (my HR representative). The day previous to the aforementioned meeting I was summoned to appear before Ms.Funkhouser. Mr. Bezanis and Mr. Jeff Andrews were present in the conference room as I entered. Feeling intimidated, I requested that I meet with Ms. Funkhouser privately the next day in order to submit a formal complaint regarding the EEO, as agreed previously. She refused and continued with what I can only describe as adisciplinary by accusing me of excessive use of Enron property and equipment. I was suspended and sent home with pay with possible termination. Ms. Funkhouser explained that her actions were based on the following:

- the assumption that I was making long distance personal calls from work
- that I was making jobapplications by company email

Unequal Employment Opportunities and Unfair Treatment.

As a manager, Mr. Bezanis has:

- Intentionally and consistently limited my employment opportunities in terms of training and performance appraisals. He has repeatedly disapproved of my training courses without good cause since he refuses to explain his disapproval.

- Shown unfavorable bias towards my job performance (PRC process) which according to the PRC rules should be judged also by my peers' and clients' by review. Until now, Iam still have not been informed of my PRC results.

- Made efforts to suppress my innovative ideas such as that of creating an 'energy index' as a potential useful trading instrument. My idea was warmly welcomed by the team in the Department Offsite, but the reaction of Mr. Bezanis was of anger for not going through him first. I was banned by him from developing the idea further.


It is our belief that Mr. Bezanis has difficulty dealing with women employees, especially competent women, as equals. His rough, stifling, and unfair management style has led to the resignation of Ms. Courtney Campbell, the other only woman reporting to him.

Hostile Working Environment.

The working environment under Mr. Bezanis has been an intimidating and abusive one. Derogatory language offensive to women is frequent and common. Very little respect is paid to our integrity and intelligence. We are managed by "threats" rather than constructive comments.

Wrongful Termination.

Knowing I was unfairly treated, Enron HR has not helped address my concerns. I was told that my employment is to be terminated due to my lowest ranking in the mid-year PRC process. Ms. Cindy Olson admitted that the PRC practices might be unfair, but she said she had no power to re-open the past PRC cases. I feel I have been subjected to a victimization campaign while the whole Enron organization attempts to protect the managers, no matter how wrong they are. I request your attention and help during my most difficult time.

I thank you for your understanding and commitment to a happy and positive resolution in this case.

Yours sincerely,

Mingcheng Lian